Dog toy gift ideas

We don't sell pet treats, toys or accessories - we make cards, pin badges and prints in the UK. Nothing below is us selling you a chew toy.

The best dog toy gift matches the dog, not the shelf. A power chewer wrecks a plush in minutes, and a senior dog with worn teeth can't enjoy a hard rubber bone.

If you're unsure, go for a stuffable rubber toy: it suits most dogs, most ages and most households.

For strong chewers

• Solid natural rubber toys rated for heavy chewing, sized up rather than down.
• Rubber chew rings you can smear with pate or peanut butter and freeze.
• Tough rope tugs with tight weave, for supervised play only.
• Skip plush, thin vinyl and anything with a squeaker that can be chewed out.

For puppies

• Soft rubber teethers that can go in the freezer to soothe sore gums.
• A snuffle mat, which tires a puppy out faster than a walk does.
• Small plush toys with no beads, buttons or plastic eyes.
• A puppy-sized stuffable toy, which becomes the crate-time toy for years.

For senior or gentle dogs

• Soft plush comfort toys with reinforced seams and no hard parts.
• Slow-release lickmats, which give a tired dog something to do lying down.
• Easy puzzle feeders with big sliders rather than fiddly lids.
• Lightweight fetch toys they can carry without straining a jaw.

Safety checks before you wrap it

• Nothing small enough to swallow whole, and no detachable eyes or ribbons.
• Sized for the dog's mouth - too small is a choking risk, too big is just ignored.
• No tennis balls for hard chewers; the fuzz wears teeth down over time.
• Include a note that rope and plush toys are for supervised play.

Browse all cards

How to write it so it lands

• Match the toy to chew strength, not to how cute it looks.
• No detachable parts, no swallowable pieces.
• Rubber stuffable toys are the safe default gift.

Where to shop next

• Safe treats to give as a pet gift
• Cat toy gift ideas
• Dog accessory gift ideas
• Cat accessory gift ideas
• Pet gifts to avoid
• New pet gift ideas
• Pet safe birthday cake and treats
• Gotcha day ideas
• Pet guides
• All guides
• Planning the party? Birthday party ideas
• How to make a balloon arch
• Photo booth prop ideas
• Pin badges

Frequently asked questions

What's the safest dog toy to give as a gift?

A solid natural rubber stuffable toy in the right size. It suits nearly every dog, lasts, and doubles as a treat dispenser.

Are tennis balls bad for dogs?

For occasional fetch they're fine, but the abrasive fuzz wears enamel down on dogs who chew them constantly. Rubber fetch balls are kinder.

How do I pick a toy size?

Too big to fit fully in the mouth, small enough to carry. If in doubt, size up.