Murder Mystery Party For Beginners: How To Run One Properly
Share
A murder mystery party is a dinner party where everyone has a secret and one person did it. Hosted well it's the best night of the year; hosted badly it's six people reading paragraphs at each other.
The difference is almost entirely in the preparation.
Kit or write your own
This initial step suits first-time hosts who want a stress-free evening of suspense without the headache of plotting a complex crime. You should make this decision right at the start of your planning process. A brilliant practical tip is to always check your guest count before buying, as this ensures nobody is left out of the mystery on the night.
- For a first one, buy a kit. Downloadable kits give you character sheets, clues, a solution and a running order for a few pounds a head.
- Check the player count carefully - most kits have a fixed number of characters and some need exactly that many.
- Look for a kit with 'flexible' or 'expandable' casting if you're unsure who's coming.
- Boxed kits are prettier; downloads are cheaper and you can print more copies.
- Writing your own is a full weekend of work. Do it on your second or third, not your first.
Casting and inviting
This stage suits planners who want to get their friends enthusiastic well before the event. Use these matching strategies during the invitation phase to ensure everyone feels comfortable with their assigned roles. As a practical tip, try to pair your guests with characters that match their natural energy levels, which keeps the evening flowing beautifully and ensures a relaxed, enjoyable atmosphere for all.
- Send character assignments a week ahead so people can think about a costume, not the night before.
- Give the loudest people the characters with the most to hide, and quieter guests characters with a clear, easy secret.
- Never cast the murderer as someone who hates being the centre of attention - and don't tell anyone else who it is, obviously.
- Be clear in the invitation about the level of costume expected. 'A hat and a scarf' is a kinder instruction than '1920s'.
- Someone will drop out. Pick your kit knowing you might need to fold a character in, and read the kit's instructions for that in advance.
The running order
Perfect for hosts who want a seamless, structured evening, this timeline keeps the suspense building without feeling rushed. You should refer to this schedule during the party itself to keep the momentum going between courses. A helpful practical tip is to keep a physical copy of the schedule hidden behind the bar, allowing you to guide your guests effortlessly through the drama.
- Arrival and drinks, everyone in character, name badges with character names on.
- Round one before the food: the host reads the scene, everyone introduces their character out loud.
- The murder is announced, usually between the first and second course.
- Rounds two and three between courses - each round hands out new clues and lets people question each other.
- Accusations written down privately before the reveal, so everyone commits.
- The reveal, read by the host, then the murderer explains. Give them the floor - it's their moment.
Food, drink and the practical bits
This section suits host-cooks who want to enjoy the party rather than spending the entire night trapped in the kitchen. Use these smart preparation strategies on the morning of the event to minimise your hosting duties. A top practical tip is to choose a menu that requires very little last-minute assembly, giving you plenty of time to focus on your guests.
- Cook something that sits in the oven. You cannot host and plate a starter at the same time.
- A buffet or a slow-cooked one-pot is the standard answer.
- Name badges, pens, and a printed clue envelope per round, labelled, in order.
- Music low, phones face down, and a clear 'we're in character now' moment at the start.
- Allow three hours. Four with a big group.
When it stalls
This advice suits quick-thinking hosts who want to keep the energy high and ensure everyone stays entertained. Keep these troubleshooting techniques in your back pocket for those quiet moments midway through the game. A great practical tip is to focus entirely on the fun of the plot rather than worrying about the accuracy of anyone's accents, keeping the mood light and easy.
- If nobody's talking, the host asks direct questions in character - 'and where exactly were you at nine o'clock?'
- Give a mid-round nudge clue if two rounds have gone by with no accusations.
- One or two people will stay out of character all night. Let them. Don't make it awkward.
- Don't police accents or period detail. The plot is the game, not the performance.
- Take a group photo at the start, while everyone's still in the costume.
Key things to remember
- Buy a kit for your first one.
- Character sheets out a week early, not on the night.
- Cook something that sits in the oven.
You might also be interested in...
View product
At Home Murder Mystery
Bring the intrigue of a classic whodunnit to your next gathering with this engaging At Home Murder Mystery game. It makes a wonderful gift for any keen host who loves entertaining friends with an evening of suspenseful fun.
View product
Murder Mystery Advent Calendar for Adults: Wreck The Halls
This clever Murder Mystery Advent Calendar for Adults: Wreck The Halls brings a thrilling daily dose of sleuthing to the traditional festive countdown. It is the perfect December treat for true crime enthusiasts and armchair detectives who prefer a little mystery with their Christmas celebrations.
Amazon · £30.00
View product
Cryptic Killers Unsolved murder mystery game - Cold Case Files Investigation Detective clues/evidence - Solve the crime - For individuals, date nights & party g
Step into the shoes of a detective with this immersive unsolved murder mystery game, packed with cold case files and realistic clues to examine. It is the perfect present for amateur sleuths, ideal for suspenseful date nights or lively parties.
Amazon · £19.99
View product
Unsolved murder mystery game - Cold Case Files Investigation - CRYPTIC KILLERS - Detective Evidence & Crime File - individuals, date nights & party games- "Murd
This immersive cold case file investigation game challenges players to solve an unsolved murder mystery using realistic detective evidence. It is the ultimate present for true crime enthusiasts, perfect for date nights, solo sleuths, or hosting suspenseful party games.
Amazon · £19.99
Frequently asked questions
How do you host a murder mystery party for the first time?
Buy a kit rather than writing your own, send character sheets a week ahead, cook something that sits in the oven, and run it in rounds between courses with clue envelopes prepared in advance. Allow three hours.
How many people do you need for a murder mystery party?
Most kits are written for six to twelve. Check the exact count before buying, and choose a kit with flexible casting if you're not sure who's coming - someone always drops out.
How long does a murder mystery party take?
About three hours for six to eight people, closer to four for a bigger group. The rounds sit between courses, so it runs at the speed of dinner.
What if someone drops out of a murder mystery party?
Good kits include instructions for removing or combining characters - read that section before the day. Failing that, the host can read the missing character's key facts aloud as a letter or witness statement.
Do you have to dress up for a murder mystery party?
No, and saying so in the invitation gets more people to come. Suggest one item - a hat, a scarf, a tie - rather than a full costume, and everyone turns up.
Do you sell games, kits or party supplies?
No - we make greeting cards, art prints and pin badges in the UK. Everything recommended here is either free, an app, or something you already have, and the only products on this page are our own cards.
Where to shop next
- TikTok and viral party games
- Phone-based party games
- Party games that use one phone only
- Escape room at home and puzzle nights
- How to run a quiz night
- Alcohol-free party games
- Games night for people who hate games
- Board games hub
- Adult birthday party games
- Traditional British party games
- Pen and paper games
- Free feel good tools
- Shop cards
- Planning the party? Birthday party ideas
- How to make a balloon arch
- Photo booth prop ideas
- Pin badges
- All guides
Cards drawn and printed by us
Funny, rude and warm greeting cards for every occasion, blank inside, printed in the UK with kraft envelopes. Order on a working day and it usually goes out the same day.
Happy Birthday Papa (Happy Birthday Card) (Multiple designs)
£3.99
Yoda Best Multi-Occasion Greeting Card
£3.99
Happy Birthday Bab (Happy Birthday Card) (Multiple designs)
£3.99
Happy Birthday Handsome (Happy Birthday Card) (Multiple designs)
£3.99
You Old Bastard (Funny Birthday Card)
£3.99
Happy Birthday Card For The World's Best Step Dad
£3.99
Found your words? Now find the card
Shop cards TikTok and viral party games Phone-based party games Party games that use one phone only