How To Choose A Birthday Card They Will Actually Keep

The best birthday card is not the funniest one on the shelf - it is the one that sounds like your relationship with the person receiving it.

Work through tone, then age, then the practical checks below.

Match the tone to the relationship

Finding the right sentiment suits anyone on your birthday list, whether you are writing to a lifelong best friend or a new workmate. Use this approach when you want to avoid that awkward moment of a joke falling flat. A great practical tip is to read the front card message aloud to ensure it matches the natural way you normally speak to them.

  • Close friend: funny works, and in-jokes work better.
  • Parent or grandparent: warm beats clever almost every time.
  • Partner: sentimental is safe; a running joke is safer still if you have one.
  • Colleague: cheerful and neutral - nothing about their age or their drinking.
  • Someone having a hard year: pick warm, not jokey.

Milestone ages

This guide suits family members and friends who are marking one of life's major transition points. You should use this advice when selecting a card for those big, zero-ending birthdays that feel particularly significant. As a practical tip, always buy these cards a little earlier than usual so you have plenty of time to gather signatures from other loved ones.

  • 18th and 21st: mark the number, keep the joke kind.
  • 30th and 40th: "over the hill" humour has aged badly - go celebratory.
  • 50th, 60th and beyond: numbered cards are appreciated, especially for a big party.
  • For any milestone, leave space - people write more on these.

Practical checks before you buy

This checklist suits busy senders who want to avoid common post-purchase mistakes. Use these quick checks at the final stage of shopping, just before you head to the till. Our best practical tip is to carry a small pen with you to test how the paper handles ink, ensuring your handwritten message will not smudge.

  • Is there enough blank space for what you want to write?
  • Is it flat enough to post as a standard Letter?
  • Does the printed verse already say what you were going to say?
  • Would they show it to someone else, or hide it?

How to write it so it lands

  • Buy two cards for people you always end up buying late for.
  • Check the inside before you buy - the verse does half the work.
  • Write the card at the shop counter if you know you will forget.

You might also be interested in...

LimaLima Funny Best Friend Birthday Card for Women Friend with Humour Besties Are Like Big Knickers Design View product

LimaLima Funny Best Friend Birthday Card for Women Friend with Humour Besties Are Like Big Knickers Design

This cheeky birthday card from LimaLima features a humorous "Besties Are Like Big Knickers" design that is sure to bring a smile to their face. It is the perfect choice for your best friend or a close woman friend who appreciates a good laugh on her special day.

Amazon · £3.99

Frequently asked questions

Is a funny card ever the wrong call?

Yes - for a first birthday card to an in-law, for anyone going through a rough year, and for milestone ages people are sensitive about.

Blank inside or printed verse?

Blank if you have something to say, printed if you do not. A printed verse plus "love from" is better than a blank card with nothing in it.

How early should I buy it?

A week ahead for posting, a fortnight for anything going overseas.

What is a good example of how to choose a birthday card?

"Close friend: funny works, and in-jokes work better." is one of 13 examples on this page. Pick the one closest to the tone you want, then add a specific detail of your own - a shared memory, a date, a name - so it reads as yours rather than copied.

More ideas you might like

Answer This - Friends - How Well Do You Know Your Family & Friends? - Fun Party Card Game for Teens & Adults - Great Conversation Starter View product

Answer This - Friends - How Well Do You Know Your Family & Friends? - Fun Party Card Game for Teens & Adults - Great Conversation Starter

This entertaining party card game is a brilliant conversation starter designed to test how well you really know your nearest and dearest. It makes a wonderful gift for teens and adults who love hosting lively games nights and sharing plenty of laughs.

Amazon · £21.99

Where to shop next

Never miss the birthday again

Pop in the date and we'll email you a reminder two weeks before, with a link to the right cards. No spam, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Back to blog